The class contained some vibrant and some more reserved students. The second chemistry class of the semester began with an experiment involving 14 out of 40 students as the subjects. These 14 students were singled out to stand in front of the rest of the class. There weren't told why, but just that it was an experiment. They were threatened with a grade cut if they refused to participate. The professor, warned that she would treat them as if she was a military commander. They were each given a number and were commanded by the professor to speak only when their number was addressed. They were to respond only to their number and answer questions prefaced with yes Dr. Anonymous. They weren't questioned regarding the actual content of the class, but rather questions regarding their ratio to that of the rest of the class, along with other very obvious questions regarding the classroom demographics. After only one class, when the teacher had not yet learned all of their names, these 14 students were told that they were the culprits contributing the noise during the previous lecture. These select students were threatened with strict repercussions if they were to talk or interrupt during any future classes.They were forbidden from sitting directly next one another in future classes, with threats of consequences if they disobeyed.
This experiment was not randomized, nor was it related to the content of the class. The students were singled out, they were explicitly chosen to stand and face the other students; they were humiliated, criticized, and belittled in front of 26 other students. There was no proof that any of these 14 students had even opened their mouths during the previous class, yet they were selected as a whole. They were selected as a group, humiliated as a group; and without any solid proof that any single individual caused any disruption during the previous lecture.
26 other students watched as 14 of their peers were selected to be humiliated only because they shared a similarity as a group. 26 individuals watched and didn't flinch, as 14 of their peers were selected by the mare fact that they were different. No one questioned, no one spoke up. 26 students, watched, and observed, yet they remained silent.
This story did not occur during the Holocaust, or during Africa's Apartheid. Nor did this happen in a segregated America. It happened in an American university, in the year 2011.
When the University was notified, at first they did nothing but blame the students that perhaps they did in fact cause a disruption and were deserving of such reprimanding. With a bit of further pressure a senior member of the chemistry department came to proctor the next lecture, but no one was singled out for special treatment during his presence. At that point he continued to excuse the professor's actions. No apologies were made, and no action was taken to address the fact that 14 students were segregated from their peers and humiliated without just cause or reason.
What if those 14 students were the only black students in the class, or the only 14 Asians, or the only 14 women? The possible discriminatory lists goes on. Perhaps the professor would receive some sort of discipline for her actions, the story might make it to the tabloids, or a even a local newspaper's front page article. What happened to our country that headlines " All men are created equal"? Of the first breakthroughs in American history fighting and impacting changes to American segregation, occurred in the educational system, with Brown vs Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas". Court had then ruled then that segregation in education is inherently unequal. Yet, in 2011, 14 students are segregated from their class of 40 students, and their peers and faculty are silent.
What happened to standing up for what is right? During World War II, the world was silent as millions were singled out and killed. Back then people blamed silence on fear for their lives. Has society not progressed since 1945? Are we raising children to succumb to the "Bystander Effect"? Are we meant to stand quietly when inequality is resurfacing in the 21 century?
5 years later, I remember standing up there like it happened today. I was number 13. My face still blushes with humiliation when I recall being addressed as a number. As an individual, with an intense love for learning, I was an active participant who sat in the front of the class and raised my hand to answer questions. However, I belonged to the Jewish Cohort in the University, and so I was made to stand out to be flushed with embarrassment in front of my peers. My friends in the class who were excluded from this experiment made no mention of the episode during later socializing or in study groups. It was as if the air of my humiliation just fluttered silently into the universe with an unknown destination. Although I attempted to file a harassment claim on the university's portal, I had received no response. I blamed it on a possible glitch in the system. But inside I wasn't ready to face speaking up, and was silently grateful for the ignored response.
I thought I had won it over when I passed the course with a great grade, and when I graduated and passed my board certification to become an RN. I felt as a real victor when I received the job I yearned for since I made the decision to become a nurse.
Yet just the other day at work I paged a member of one the hospital teams and introduced myself as Devorah from 11 east. The individual confirmed her recollection of who I was by asking " Oh are you that cute little Jewish girl with the stylish scrubs with those wild curls and funky glasses?" Aside from being humbly, flattered by her detailed description of myself, I felt grateful to be working in a place where I am a proud, unique individual; but never singled out because of my differences. In fact I have only been met with respect for my differences, and have never been excluded or made to feel separate from my peers. I realized that being different and belonging to a specific group or race doesn't warrant any form of segregation, or humiliation. In fact in my case, it is how I am recognized and remembered.
Yet just the other day at work I paged a member of one the hospital teams and introduced myself as Devorah from 11 east. The individual confirmed her recollection of who I was by asking " Oh are you that cute little Jewish girl with the stylish scrubs with those wild curls and funky glasses?" Aside from being humbly, flattered by her detailed description of myself, I felt grateful to be working in a place where I am a proud, unique individual; but never singled out because of my differences. In fact I have only been met with respect for my differences, and have never been excluded or made to feel separate from my peers. I realized that being different and belonging to a specific group or race doesn't warrant any form of segregation, or humiliation. In fact in my case, it is how I am recognized and remembered.
Upon recollecting my day on my way home, and feeling suddenly grateful for my differences, I was brought back to the day when being different had me separated as a number, and I realized that I too am slightly guilty of chaining this story to silence. I didn't speak up then, yet inside blamed others for their silence. Perhaps back then I was still afraid of my status in school, my grades and the possibility of it impending my graduating with honors. Now I confidently embrace my differences, I don't want to succumb to the "Bystander Effect". I don't want to be silent like the cowards in my chemistry class and the faculty in my University, because what example will that be to my peers and those around me?
It takes only one small voice to shatter a glass of silence. Perhaps, someday little Jewish nurse D, with stylish scrubs and tousled curls can be that voice.
It takes only one small voice to shatter a glass of silence. Perhaps, someday little Jewish nurse D, with stylish scrubs and tousled curls can be that voice.
.


